Despite my love for LaTeX typesetting, even I am forced to admit that the edit-compile-preview cycle lacks the immediacy of other inferior but WYSIWYG solutions. This is not always a problem, but it sometimes is. "Instant Preview" (IP for short) is a potential (if not yet fully realized), almost complete, best-of-both-worlds solution.
What is Instant Preview?
A picture is worth a thousand words; but, in this case, a Flash animation is worth even more. Take a look at this page, which demonstrates IP as implemented in a TeX distribution for Windows called BaKoMa TeX (I hope I got the capitalization right). Basically, you enter text in an edit window, and the output file is automatically regenerated and redisplayed on each keystroke, thereby giving the illusion of actually working "in the PDF file" (or, for BaKoMa TeX, in the DVI file, TeX’s older output format). IP was most famously implemented in the TeXtures TeX system for traditional Mac OS; Whizzytex is a well-known Emacs-based solution that achieves the same effect.
On modern Mac OS X there are two solutions (that I know of). One is the brand-new Latexian text editor, which features a built-in IP mode, but is fairly slow. The other is Flashmode, a solution by Claus Gerhardt based on the well-known TeXshop integrated editor and previewer. I decided to experiment with Flashmode this week.
Flashmode: installation and use
First of all, if you have the MacTeX LaTeX distribution, you most likely already have TeXshop. Then, you need to obtain Flashmode itself from Claus Gerhardt’s page; download the TeXhelpers package, which also contains other goodies. The Flashmode software comes with an exhaustive manual; however, let me point out a few caveats that caused me minor headaches and wasted time.
- After opening the TeXhelpers DMG (disk image) file, you must copy both the Flashmode and the Local Switcher apps to your Applications folder; you will need them both
- For some reason, neither Flashmode nor Local Switcher are indexed by Spotlight. So, if you are like me and launch most software (that you don’t already have on your Dock) using Spotlight, you’re out of luck: you need to open the Applications folder, or install scripts that launch Flashmode from inside TeXshop. Of course, you can also put Flashmode in your dock.
- You must create links to your current TeX distribution in your home directory: this is what Local Switcher is for. Fortunately, this is to be done only when you first install Flashmode, and every time you update or change your TeX distro. Note: the Flashmode manual states that you no longer need to create these symlinks, but my experience is that you do need them. [Update:Claus has just released a new version, numbered 6.1, that addresses this issue.]
- Finally, every TeX file you work on must have a format directive as its first line: that is, the very first line must be something like
%&pdflatex, by itself (if the file is to be compiled using pdflatex; otherwise, e.g.
After installation, Flashmode is relatively painless to use. You open a tex file in TeXshop, perhaps typeset it once, then launch Flashmode and press the "Run Flashmode" button while the tex source file is the topmost window in TeXshop, right below the Flashmode window. Once again, make sure that the very first line of your file contains the text
%pdflatex, by itself. Then you basically forget about it, and just watch as typeset PDF text automagically materializes in your preview window as you type in the source window. If there is a TeX/LaTeX error, the preview window is simply not updated. When you are done editing your file, switch to the Flashmode window and click the "Quit Flashmode" button. Read the manual for further information.
Now, before you get your hopes up: this thing is not really real-time preview. Working on a small- to medium-sized file, the PDF output gets updated maybe once every 1 or 2 seconds. However, after using Flashmode for a while, a strange thing happens: the source window sort of "fades in the background", and you tend to focus more on the output window. I mean this in a new-agey, psychological sense, not literally of course: you sort of stop paying attention exclusively to the TeX source, and rely a lot more on the PDF output.
I realized that this was happening because I did not find TeXshop’s editor frustrating, which I usually do (addicted as I am to TextMate). In particular, syntax highlighting is really minimal in TeXshop, but in the end it does not matter that much, because you can see the actual typeset output materialize before your eyes, without user intervention.
I think the killer application for Flashmode are Beamer presentations. As long as presentations are short (I tried a 130-slides one, including transitions, and it really didn’t work that well), you can approximate Powerpoint-like interactivity, while enjoying all the advantages of LaTeX typesetting.
Bottom line: I need to experiment more, but the results so far are intriguing. Incidentally, I tried Flashmode on my office iMac (3 GHz, early 2008 vintage) and my Macbook Pro (2.5 GHz, also early 2008 vintage). Not exactly the fastest machines you can lay your hands on. So, your mileage may be even better than mine.
Behind the scenes
Based on Flashmode’s manual, the software works as follows. An Applescript (Apple’s own scripting language) sits in the background, polling TeXshop to see if the topmost document window is "dirty", i.e. contains unsaved text. If so, the script asks TeXshop to save the file, then typesets the document and refreshes the output window.
According to the manual, this is all Flashmode does. However, there are two, maybe three well-known behind-the-scenes tricks to speed up IP. Flashmode perhaps uses the first one, but I’m not sure. In a way, I hope it doesn’t, because this would imply that there is scope for further speed-up! Anyway, here is a brief description of the tricks. [Update: Claus Gerhardt just confirmed to me that Flashmode does not use any such trick.]
The format-file trick. Remember that LaTeX is just a set of macros written in the more basic TeX language. When you compile a LaTeX source file, the
pdftex command-line program first loads the LaTeX "format file", a pre-compiled version of the LaTeX macros. More often than not, before you actually start typing any text, your file has a series of
\usepackage commands (e.g. for bibliography, theorems, AMS fonts, etc.) that provide additional macros; finally, you may define your own macros in the TeX file. Every time you compile, all those packages, not to mention your own macros, have to be read and compiled. The idea is then to create a new format file that includes all of LaTeX, plus the specific packages and macros that you include in your own tex source file. This needs to be done only once, using the
initex command-line utility; then, instead of compiling your original file with, say,
pdflatex, you strip the preamble (the initial part of the file containing package invocations and macro definitions) and compile only the actual text with
pdftex, specifying the pre-generated format file as additional compiled input. With complex macro packages, this can make a big difference. TextMate’s Watch document command in the LaTeX bundle uses this trick.
Slicing. This trick involves some complex coordination between the editor and LaTeX itself; Whizzytex is a particularly fast implementation. The idea is that, if one can figure out which output page contains the text currently being edited, one need only recompile that particular page ("slice"), not the entire document. Obviously, this can make a huge difference in terms of speed. In particular, longer documents do not slow down the interaction, because in any event only the current page is recompiled. I suspect this would be fantastic in conjunction with Beamer. Whizzytex keeps track of the current page by using a specially-crafted LaTeX style file, but I wonder whether a similar trick could be implemented using the built-in synctex facilities.
Low-level interaction with tex. This is a bit vague, so let me explain. Whenever you run any of the
tex programs, the operating system has to load them into memory (which is pretty fast nowadays, at least on the second and subsequent runs); then, the software has to go through a sequence of initialization operations. Only after such operations have been completed can processing of actual source files begin. Hence the idea, due to Jonathan Fine, to essentially keep
tex running as a background process, or daemon, and feed it source files as needed, without actually going through the initialization sequence each time. Obviously, this requires tinkering with TeX’s source code. It’s way above my pay grade🙂
As a final consideration, it is worth pointing out that all these techniques were originally developed to handle DVI output. But DVI is a much simpler format, so actually displaying a DVI file is considerably (as in, an order of magnitude) faster than displaying a PDF file. Thus, in principle, one could think of using DVI as the output format of choice for IP. However, this is not satisfactory for two reasons: first, there is no native DVI previewer on the Mac (Skim turns the DVI into a PDF); second, Beamer and the TikZ graphics package do not fully support DVI output (if at all).
Right now, I think that, after this experiment, I will likely go back to my usual TextMate-based, traditional workflow. Incidentally, the Watch Document command in the LaTeX bundle implements 50% of IP: it regenerates the PDF output each time the source file is saved.
However, I wonder whether something like Flashcode could be implemented for TextMate. This largely depends upon the commands exposed via Applescript; I need to investigate! On the other hand, I am pretty sure that Flashcode could be implemented in Sublime Text, without even touching Applescript, and hence in a fully portable way. The Events and Idle-Watcher examples in the documentation for Sublime Text plugins are tantalizing…